Union busting is big business

www.nominateducate.com
www.nominateducate.com

Union busting is big business

By Ben Zipperer and John Schmitt MinutemanMedia.org Published Friday, July 06, 2007

As the percentage of American workers in unions continues its long and severe decline, the Senate just voted to kill the Employee Free Choice Act. What prompted the now-dormant bill, and what is causing the weakening of the labor movement, is not a decreased need for unions. According to polls, about half of non-supervisory workers want to join one, but employers are increasingly breaking the law to prevent their workplaces from being unionized.

Fifty years ago, more than 30 percent of private-sector workers were organized. That share today is 8 percent. Globalization and the new, technology-driven economy have contributed to this decline, but advanced economies in Europe survive these same developments with union coverage rates as high as 80 percent. Much of the falloff is actually the result of illegal, anti-union actions by employers. Our recent analysis of cases brought before the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), which oversees union-management relations in most of the private sector, shows that employers illegally fire as many as 1 in 5 union organizers. 

Actions by the world's largest employer are a case in point. When butchers at Wal-Mart's Jacksonville, Texas, store joined the United Food and Commercial Workers International Union, Wal-Mart permanently closed its meat-cutting departments, switched to pre-packaged meat, and fired four of the union supporters.

Just picking on Wal-Mart is unfair, as much of the business community also despises unions. Unions fight for increased wages and benefits and for redistributing earnings from employers to workers. Corporate managers, on the other hand try to maximize profits for shareholders and compensation packages for those at the top. Compelled by the threat of lower profits, many employers will do whatever it takes to avoid a union workplace.

Not infrequently, this means breaking the law. The National Labor Relations Act (NRLB) makes it illegal to intimidate or fire workers for union activity. Yet, according to our study of data from the NLRB, there has been a steep rise in illegal firings of pro-union workers in the last few years. Currently, 1 in 53 is dumped during an election campaign. And employers generally fire the workers who are leading the union organizing drives. If 10 percent of union supporters are actually organizers in their workplace, NLRB data show that about 1 in 5 is fired illegally for their activism.

Interestingly, union membership has actually increased in the public sector. Whereas the private sector — the bulk of the U.S. economy — has seen unionization fall by three-quarters over the last 50 years, public-sector union membership has tripled over the same period to about 36 percent. Persistent, illegal activity by employers in the private sector explains this disparity. Illegal firings exist in the public sector too, of course, but they are less prevalent. Additional civil service protections ensure that firings are more onerous to the government than they are to a business. Besides, we should expect less union busting in the public sector: There is no profit motive there. 

President Dwight D. Eisenhower once lambasted union busters, proclaiming, "Only a fool would try to deprive working men and women of the right to join the union of their choice." The fools today are actually quite rational, practicing the cool calculus of costs and benefits.

In a worst-case scenario, the cost of firing a union supporter isn't that much. It includes legal proceedings and remuneration to the discharged employee. At a maximum, discharged employees will receive missed earnings minus any income they have earned in the meantime. The total award usually amounts to less than $4,000, a small price to pay to avoid sharing profits with employees through a union-negotiated contract.

In its vote, the Senate eliminated the opportunity to increase fines and make other changes to labor law that reduce the incentives for illegal employer aggression. But without those reforms, crime really does pay.

Ben Zipperer is a researcher and John Schmitt is senior economist at the Center for Economic and Policy Research in Washington, D.C. — www.cepr.net


Important information

At the bottom of this article you will see the following two paragraphs, which i believe are the most important in regard to EFCA ... and why the EFCA should be taken to the polls in 2008.

In a worst-case scenario, the cost of firing a union supporter isn't that much. It includes legal proceedings and remuneration to the discharged employee. At a maximum, discharged employees will receive missed earnings minus any income they have earned in the meantime. The total award usually amounts to less than $4,000, a small price to pay to avoid sharing profits with employees through a union-negotiated contract.

In its vote, the Senate eliminated the opportunity to increase fines and make other changes to labor law that reduce the incentives for illegal employer aggression. But without those reforms, crime really does pay.

 

 


I realize now

There is a serious problem with the Rank and File Member being blind to these issues. I have had numourous conversations with members in my own organization and they seem not to be in loop of what is going on, the reasons baffle me, I wonder if it is all worth the effort for such people as yourself that put so much work into the cause. Websites like this one are rarely being viewed by union members. you can see Richard, Unions are'nt stangers in the political alley regarding organinzing, I realize now that it is not one of their top priorities.

Please Keep Up the Great Work You Are Doing...

In Solidarity, 

Charles Lezette

Carpenters Local 370

Albany, NY


Stay encouraged

I know ...

I thought to just leave the comment "I know," but thought to try to elaborate a little, or as best I can.

There are many rank-and-file members that don't give crap about what we are doing, what is happening in their locals, etc., some friends of mine in the City tell me, "Look man, I am happy to be working ... anything beyond that is gravy." With that kind of mindset we stagnate - if not move backwards.

Can unions do a better job organizing new workers? Absolutely. Can unions do a better job informing current members of various things that are taking place? Absolutely. Everyone, across the board can be doing a better job ...

With this site and my work, it is just a drop in the bucket of what is really needed to make big huge changes in our working worlds. It is important for me to focus on the tiny victories rather than the huge defeats -- it is not for me to remain in some delusional state, but rather to keep me encouraged as well.

When I think about tiny "victories" that you and I and a few others are doing all I have to do is look at the traffic of this site. Right now we have a community visiting these pages that triples the numbers from 60 days ago. Clearly this means that there is a hole in labor communications and online organizing.

I am devoting about the same amount of time to this site as I am a full-time job, and it is working. Can you imagine what more would / could happen with some funding to keep me going a little longer? Can you imagine 10 people doing the same amount of work? I think about that a lot -- maybe take some ads to the site, cross-reference it with my freelance work, anything to keep it growing and getting stronger, maybe one day be able to pay someone to work with this site .... it is good to dream, but reality is reality ... and reality is that right now -- aside from a few others, right now it is me and you kid.

As for the unions: We both know that there are certain things that should change and will change ... but not overnight. If the people that make up the unions are you, Richard, me, others ... we need to get others like ourselves coming out to these pages to talk about things -- even if it is to admit they don't know anything about their unions, their contracts, their rights. I have a strong hunch that we have many in our ranks that should be re-organized into the same fold they are already paying dues to -- that is clearly the case in your local from what I am hearing.

Anyway, I am writing all this out to you because, as I mentioned, you need to stay encouraged to keep this going with me and others. You are a vital part of this community and I can't let you get to the point of feeling you are just wasting your time ... it is not the case, trust me on this.

-Richard  


There are time for changes

We do not find ourselves in one of those periods. But we must continue to beat the drum so that when that time does come, we can bring that change about. Also, beating the drum does make a difference. Think about the one person who stumbles on this site who really didn't know much about labor unions and was inspired to learn more about them because of it. And I know Richard has great plans for this site so that it does make a difference. But there's no doubt in my mind it will. It's not going to change the labor movement overnight, but at least we can sleep well knowing we've done our part.

This site is now getting 30K page views per month by flesh and blood people. A lot of people are out there and they are reading and we've only just started. Keep that in mind, bro. Thanks for your contributions and input.


Walmart

You comment "its not fair to just pick on Walmart."  I feel this is just a beginning for the union to take action and show their strength. 

Our strength has weakened for many reasons but I feel if all union members came together and refused to shop at one of the biggest anti union companies, it could only be a good thing. A message would be heard by the board of directors and its share holders.

I personally dont understand how any union member can in good conscience support this company.

Walmart is the only company that I am aware of that on orientation day will show first, an anti union film. All companies I have ever worked for, their first film has always been safety.

If all union members said no to walmart I believe it could make a difference in our fight.  And then if we passed this boycott to our family and friends, imagine the impact we could make. Of course, we wouldnt stop with them.


Stocks

How about if your Local Union Officer stands up at a meeting and preachs about the evils of Walmart and demands a boycott. How about the same Local who has 5000 shares of Walmart in its Pension Stock Portfolio and the Empire State Council of Carpenters who has 30,000 shares in its portfolio. Rather odd wouldnt you say. While I agree Walmart sucks you must ask if you do not shop and support the worker or do you shop to increase the value of your Unions stock portfolio. Check your Unions 5500 to see if they have any.

regarding stocks

When I first started at walmart I thought, heck I'll buy some stock, I need to think about my retirement, I wont miss $5 or $10 out of my check.  After my 90 days I was offered health ins. I thought, gee I need ins, its got to be good, with being such a huge company, so I signed up.(and it wasnt cheap)

Well when I received all the paperwork and started reading it, I called my dad. (he is a retired ins manager) I wont go into details about it but my dad said, "Get out, get out now!"  I went to the woman that hired me and she sd, I dont think you can get out, you better speak to (the store manager) I did and he told me, no, you cant get out once you have signed up.  I went home and called my dad. He sd, BS, you can cancel at any time. I went back to the manager and sd, I want out and again he replied, I dont think you can but you can call this number.  I did and the ins reps told me the same thing, no, you cant cancel. I sd, my dad is an ins manager and I know I can.  He put me on hold.  Finally he came back and sd, well ok, we'll allow it, but only because your still within the 90 days.  Makes me wonder, how many people they have cheated. When others that have tried to get out and were told no. One good thing I did just before I left, I had a cple people come ask me what I thought about their ins, I told them, no, dont get it and then explained why.

I left them after 4 mths and they were training me to be a cashier manager. 


You have to understand one thing !!!

You have to understand one thing !!!

Many people working on a 40 hour or less work week, feel as if thet can't afford to shop anywhere else. Believe me... Alot of people that are union members shop at Wal-Mart, not because they want to... But, because they need to. There are union members that live i rural area's that just don't provide any other means of shopping & saving money.

In Solidarity, 

Charles Lezette

Carpenters Local 370

Albany, NY


Not having much choice

I know, its hard. My family lives in rural country too. I started talking to them a few years ago. They didnt understand and didnt have the info regarding all of walmart doings. It took some months but they started to understand. They told me, we havent stopped but we've cut our shopping in half. I said, thanks, anything helps! (and they too feel better)

I can suggest when going to a major city, please stock up.

Things are tight for us too. I am recouping from surgery and I havent been able to work for sometime. We shop at Kroger, they're unionized. and we get awesome coupons from them.  Approx. once a month they send us coupons for the things we actually buy. We also get $10.00 off a $100.00 order, $2.00 off in beauty (like soap) when spending $7, 3 off of ten in the deli etc....Plus you save 10 cents per gallon of gas for every $100.00 you spend. I grabbed 10 tubes of colgate for $10.00

Speaking of toothpaste, you did hear about chinas tooth paste? How about their cows? They have been feeding their cattle sewage water. Walmart being the biggest importer of chinese goods, I sure wouldnt want to buy their beef.  We also get 70% of our seafood from China and their catfish has been found to be contaminated. Speaking of food. (I saw it in the store I worked and I saw it in another state)  When people go through the line and change their minds, not wanting to purchase something they give it to the cashier. This includes perishable items.  I have seen things that should be refrigerated, sit for an hour or two and then placed back on the shelf.

Good help is hard to find. Another tip, when you shop (any where) check the expiration dates.

 

 

 


We can all do our part

A few yrs ago I came up on someones blog as I surfed the web. I cant remember much of it except for he was saying if everyone just quit buying their toothpaste from walmart it would make a difference.  How? I dont recall. I skimmed his words. It had something to do with inventory and God only knows what else.

Usually out in rural country, if theres a walmart, theres a doller general or dollar tree. My daughter gets her tp, tooth paste and cleaning supplies from them.

Have you ever seen the Robert Greenwald movie about walmart? Its got alot of info in it. Its cheap too if you buy it. Alot of times they really arent cheaper. (we're not spending much more mthly shopping at kroger than we did a few yrs back with a 10% discount) Even back then, the first time I shopped and we ate, my husband sd, I dont like the taste of this meat. So I never bought any more meat from them.

So maybe the people who think they cant afford any where but walmart, actually can. But if not, if they just stopped buying a few things from them and got them elsewhere.  (such as tooth paste, toilet paper and cleaning supplies) 

For being the biggest employer (and yes they brag that if anything happened to the federal governments computer, they would come to them) because its so sophisticated (with ordering, personel etc)  If every union member, family and friend quit buying their toothpaste from them....they would notice.

They are so anti union and they let you know. They tell you, dont let them fool you into signing a card. So maybe not buying a few items from there any more, the person can feel better. At least they are making some kind of effort. and if alot of people made the same effort, it would be noticed.


an anti union film

Have you ever seen one of these anti union films? 

 


The films mentioned

Hi,

I took a rare day and spent most of it off the computer so I am catching up now and it just past 7 ... I feel like I had a vacation.

I wanted to post a comment to Chuck's question. The worker who wrote in about Wal-Mart has written to me in private. She worked for Wal-Mart and, revealed to me, that one her first day on the job, the company had her watch anti-union films and talked other anti-union trash. 

I wanted to put that out there since I had known she witnessed this stuff first hand and was not sure when we'd see her come back ...

-Richard  


anti union film

Yes I have. I relocated to another state years ago.(where I'm at now) I needed a job and was looking for something different, outside of my experience. I tried many local businesses in my neighborhood. I got a call from walmart. (I applied before I was aware of the way they are) I went to work for them. I only worked there for 4 mths but I have a few stories.

Concerning this anti union film. I saw it. Day one at orientation.


Thanks for being with us

JustMe:

I am so thankful you are part of this community. I believe your comments and posts are really important and pivotal to our overall mission. 

Thank you, 

Richard/ UR  


warm welcome

Thank you Richard for making me feel so welcomed. I am so happy to be here. I was afraid when I made my first post, I thought being so new here maybe I was pushing my opinion too strongly.

In Solidarity, 

Justme

 


Union Busts itself

While we are all aware of the tactics of anti Union employers we cannot ignore the fact that the Unions are busting themselves. The decline cannot be blamed on the tactics of the employer alone. To do so is to ignore the true roots of the decline and therefore never take proper steps for a turn around. The propagandists want us to believe that all of a sudden the employer has come up with a magic formula that has caused the steady decline. Big business has been at this for years and there is no evidence that they have all of a sudden come up with a formula of success. If anything their ability to terrorize the worker like in the old days has decreased. While they still use their usual bag of tricks the decline of Union membership cannot be blamed on them alone. The Unions are responsible for cutting their own throats and to go along with the propagandists and ignore this and other contributing factors the decline will never be reversed. You can have all the card checks you want. It may cause a slight increase in the percentages due to the ability to extort the non Union worker by exposing his choices with a card check you will not see it reverse the decline in Union membership like the propagandists are trying to convince you it will. You have to make the non Union sector WANT to be a member and no amount of card check extortion will cause to happen. You have to convince them that Union membership is in their best interest and it appears by the decline that you have not. To blame that on the employers is just plain bullshit and if you continue to propagandize the issue we will never make positive changes.

How is the Union busting itself is quite clear. It cannot get members and it cannot keep members, I will focus on the Carpenters because I can provide first hand evidence. For years it has been the policy of our Union to keep people out. Many times I have sent people down to join and they have been turned away. We had dinosaurs in charge who could not understand that if you want to control the labor market you had to control the workers by making them card caring members. It is only in the last four years that we have finally gotten wiser. I watched for 15 years as the door sere closed. Opening the doors for the last 3 years is not going to overnight reverse a trend you created over the last 20 years. Union busting itself.

Now we have opened the doors and we continue to screw the non union sector wanting to come in. We have people coming down to join that walk away because they cannot get past a secretary. She runs the hall because our officers and organizers are at the Malta Dinner having breakfast. We have experienced Journeyman Carpenters that leave in disgust because this woman tells them they have to be first year apprentices. She acts as if she could care less if they get in or not. They take the attitude to heart and are never seen again. 27 year old Mr. Smith who had been in construction since he was 16 walks into the hall and walks out a first year apprentice because this “Person” convinced him there was an age limit to be a Journeyman. He was so discouraged we almost lost him. Despite repeated attempts to get our illustrious leaders to fix it they stalled and lied to the kid some more. Why. Because then they can provide the employers with underpaid and over experienced apprentices. THINK about what crooked bastard benefits from this arrangement. How many good Journeymen have we lost who never joined. How many have we lost that gave up after a short period? How man will never attempt to join because the word got back and they are not going to waste their time. Unions busting themselves.

Why can’t we retain members? I have had many conversations with members who have had enough of the theft and corruption and are taking the first train out. No matter how many times you try to tell them that “BY LEAVING. THE SCUM BAGS THEIVES WIN “they are leaving anyways. Our Union has been robbing its members for years and it is only getting worse. We are sitting as we speak waiting for our vacation check because our fund was stolen and they decided they are not paying us this year for another month. We usually get our check on the first of July but this year they decided to do away with our stamps and are keeping our money for another month. When asked for justification they said they didn’t have to give any, they were doing it “Because they could” This is just a small example of the corruption and arrogance in the Empire Council. One of my NLRB cases focuses on the fact that the Union is authorizing dues check payroll deductions without signed authorization forms. This is against the law, council bylaws and the negotiated contract. The council has told members that if they chose direct payment that they had to come in and pay everyday with a check BEFORE they could go to work. Again. Against the law and a clear case of coercion and in my book extortion. Even after the NLRB has ruled the extortion am unfair labor practice the Empire Council continued to do dictate the demand to all council members. The Utica NY BA told a job supervisor for Welliver and McGuire that payroll deduction was mandatory and direct payment was not allowed. He also stated that I should be jailed for telling everybody. Local 1163 in Syracuse tired to force members to sign dues check off and the PAC form as a condition of being placed on the out of work list. The NLRB put a stop to that.Our Local 370 has stolen $1.60 since January 1, 2007 in raises from its members. They held a sham vote on raise allocation without notifying the membership that a vote was taking place. They refused to even consider a dely on the vote until the members could be properly notified. Our illustrious President and Chair William “Mangina” Weir laughed and did nothing while a member was attacked by mindless members for raising this issue ands others. These were some of Local 370s finest idiots and cronies of Mr. Weir. This is just a sampling of business as usual for Local 370. Can you understand why we cannot keep members? Can you understand why we cannot get members to join? The Union is busting itself

Outside factors. My brothers are both Carpenters. One is a punch out man for COs and the other is a Framing supervisor. Both non Union. 20 years ago I was at $18.90 an hour and they were at $12 with benefits. I used to be able to tease them about how much better the Union was and try to get them to join. After 20 years of raises I am at $24.05. Why because my Union STEALS my raise every year. They lie as to the need for more money in our Pension and Health. They refuse to supply us with proof of the numbers and run through sham votes made up of their cronies. My brothers on the other hand are at $21 and $23 with full benefits. My pay increase after theft over 20 years is $5.15. By brothers are $9 and $11. My benefits are the worst bullshit program you have ever seen and declines every year despite more and more money stolen from my wage. While I cannot and will not say that all the labor markets show these increases I can safely say that the difference between pay scales of Union vs. Non Union is not as great as it was 20 years ago . The wages and benefit packages in the non Union sector have increased significantly. This is one of the external factors that we must take into account. This is one of the reasons we have lost membership. Why would a non Union worker fighting a corrupt corporate structure want to jump into another corrupt corporate structure such as the UBC without a substantial benefit increase? The Union busting itself

How do we combat this? Do we clean up our Union and stop stealing from our membership. No. Do we entice the non Union sector?No. Do we remedy the stupidity of secretaries ?No.Do we offer a better deal with more incentives such as paid vacations, the promise of a future or even the lure of Brotherhood? No. Our officers get 10 paid vacations each year.(including a paid Golf Day) and the rank and file does not. Our Officers get quarter million dollar salaries each year and we get our raise taken each year. Our Financial Secretary took $32,000 in raises over a two year period while stealing the raise of the rank and file each year. The Laborers International has 13 Vice Presidents with salaries starting at $225,000 each. The propagandists want to blame the employers. They post article after article about Union busting and other nasty employer tactics. They scour the internet seizing on any story or article that ignores the culpability of the Union and blames the employers and big business. Instead of joining attempts to clean up their Unions and stop the corruption they enable it by doing nothing. Their answer is to cheat the working man and give these corrupt scum the card check. They want to throw millions at organizing so now we can have 1000 organizers instead of 100 trying to coerce unwary non Union workers to join their corrupt organization. Cash McCarron has been throwing hard UBC funds at organizing in this manner for the last 5 years and the decline continues at an alarming rate. Wake up Dougy and your candle burning followers. The numbers have proven that your plan does not work. Yet rather than admitting the problem. Rather than putting an end to the corruption the UBC will lead the way as a shining example of how to bring the Labor movement to its demise.

As long as we ignore the problems within the Unions and fail to recognize their culpability in the fall of our membership we will never start to turn around our membership decline. In the old days of Unionism it was proving to the non Union sector of the advantages of Brotherhood. Proving that Unions could bring better wages, working conditions and health care. Then it was true. As much as the propagandists are still making these antiquated speeches filled with antiquated idealistic reasons for joining a Union we will continue to slide. This is not the modern day cry to Unionism. These antiquated calls to brotherhood is not the realism of Union membership in 2007. Perhaps it is just as simple as proving that we Union members are not the thieving scum bags that is the UBC. As simple as Proving that we rank and file still believe in Brotherhood. As simple as proving that we rank and file are capable of removing the corrupt elements that the non union sector can see is modern day Unionism. While not all Union are in this mold the UBC,McCarron, Stern.Change to Win and Little Hoffa are shining example of how far Union Labor has fallen. If McCarrons vision of Corporate Unionism is truly the future of Organized Labor then we have all lost already.